Columbia Mens Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot Review

Long days on the trail can really test your feet, especially when the weather turns wet or the terrain gets rough. If you’re logging serious miles, a dependable pair of boots can make or break your experience.

The Newton Ridge Plus II aims to bring together durability, comfort, and traction in a lighter package.

Most hikers who value solid waterproofing and dependable grip will spot the strengths here. Some folks have mentioned issues with breathability and long-term wear on the outsole, though.

If you’re stuck between comfort and durability, this boot lands somewhere in the middle. It’s solid for daily use but doesn’t feel overly bulky.

Overview: Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot

This boot tries to balance trail toughness with comfort you can use every day. Columbia uses a mix of leather and mesh to keep water out, while still letting your feet breathe a bit.

The ankle-height shape adds support, but doesn’t weigh you down.

Highlights:

• Waterproof construction keeps feet dry, but can get warm on hot days.
• Rubber outsole with multi-terrain tread grips dirt, rocks, and even a little snow.
• Lightweight midsole cushions each step, so you’re less likely to feel worn out.
• Lace-up closure lets you dial in the fit, though the break-in can feel stiff at first.

This boot works well for hikers or anyone outdoorsy who wants something sturdy but doesn’t want to pay top dollar. If you mostly hike in hot weather, though, the leather build can run warm compared to mesh-heavy shoes.

Waterproof Full-Grain Leather Construction

Columbia uses full-grain leather treated to shed water, with mesh panels to help your feet breathe. This blend aims to keep you dry but not totally stifled.

The leather feels tough and stands up to moisture. You’ll probably feel more confident splashing through puddles or light rain.

On the flip side, the leather’s a bit stiff out of the box, so expect a break-in period. The waterproofing does fine for damp trails, but if you’re trudging through streams all day, it might eventually soak through.

Columbia seems to want durability without sacrificing too much comfort, but you might need to give these boots a little time before they feel broken in.

Lightweight Comfort and Cushioning

Nobody wants to haul around heavy boots on a long hike. Columbia keeps things lighter here, with a midsole that supports but doesn’t add much bulk.

The lightweight build helps cut down on fatigue during longer walks. The cushioned midsole softens the blow of rocks and roots, which is always a plus.

You’ll get a bit of energy return with each step, which can be handy on hills. Some people find the cushioning a touch firm, though, and these aren’t the lightest hiking boots out there.

For most day hikes or weekend trips, the comfort is solid. If you’re after ultra-soft padding or featherweight shoes, you might want to look at trail runners instead.

Advanced Traction and Omni-Grip Outsole

Traction can make or break your hike, especially when things get slick. Columbia’s Omni-Grip outsole uses different tread zones to help you stay steady on dirt, wet rocks, or even a dusting of snow.

Multi-terrain patterns help reduce slips, while winter tread zones give you extra grip on icy spots. The rubber feels tough enough for regular use.

Deep tread can trap mud, though, which means you might need to scrape them clean now and then. The grip is good for hiking, but not as aggressive as what you’d get from mountaineering boots.

If you care about stability but don’t need extreme grip, this outsole should do the job. Hardcore mountaineers, though, might want something even grippier.

Breathable Mesh Design

The mesh panels, especially around the tongue and upper, help keep air moving. This can really help with heat and sweat during longer hikes.

The mesh tongue lets air in, cutting down on sweaty feet. Combining mesh and leather keeps things durable but not totally stuffy.

Still, the mesh isn’t everywhere—so in hot weather, you’ll probably notice some warmth. The focus on waterproofing means airflow isn’t as open as with super-light mesh shoes.

If you want some breathability without giving up protection, this design offers a bit of both. Just don’t expect it to feel like a sandal.

Adjustable Lace-Up Fit

A good lacing system can make all the difference on the trail. Columbia uses metal eyelets and hooks, so you can tweak the fit around your foot and ankle as you like.

You can tighten the laces for more support or loosen them if you need some wiggle room. The top hooks help keep the laces locked in, so they don’t slip during long hikes.

Some folks say the laces need re-tying if you go for a super-tight fit. The thicker laces also take a bit longer to adjust compared to quick-lace systems.

If you want a custom fit and don’t mind spending a bit more time lacing up, this boot’s design should suit you.

Versatile Outdoor Style

You can wear these boots off the trail without looking out of place. The leather and mesh combo gives them a rugged look, but they blend in with casual outfits.

Color options exist, though not everyone will love the combos. They work for both hiking trips and daily wear.

Leather adds toughness, while mesh keeps things lighter. Neutral colors make them easier to pair with jeans or hiking pants.

The chunky profile might feel a bit much for city use. And compared to sneakers, there aren’t a ton of color choices.

If you want boots that work outdoors and don’t look too out of place at the coffee shop, these do the trick—though they lean more functional than fashionable.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Waterproof build keeps feet dry on wet trails.
• Durable leather and mesh balance toughness with some airflow.
• Secure lacing helps you get a snug fit.
• Reliable traction works on dirt, rocks, and even a bit of snow.
• Cushioned midsole supports longer walks.
• Versatile style for trail or casual wear.

Cons

• Break-in period feels stiff, especially at the ankle.
• Heavier weight than some hiking shoes.
• Gets warm on hot days.
• Less flexible than trail runners.
• Runs narrow for some, so wide feet may need to size up.

Customer Reviews

Most buyers report these boots handle rough trails and wet conditions well. Waterproofing gets a lot of praise—people say their feet stay dry in rain and puddles.

Comfort stands out, especially after breaking them in. On the downside, several mention the fit runs narrow and the boots feel a bit heavier than expected.

Customer feedback highlights:

• Durability: Withstands frequent hikes.
• Waterproofing: Reliable for rainy days.
• Comfort: Supportive, but needs break-in.
• Fit: Narrow for some, sizing up can help.
• Weight: Heavier than lighter hiking options.

With an average of 4.5 stars from over 7,500 reviews, most people are happy. Sizing and weight are the main complaints.

What Sets It Apart

Columbia’s Newton Ridge Plus II stands out with its blend of classic leather durability and modern mesh breathability. It delivers solid waterproofing and a customizable lacing system, all at a price that’s accessible for most hikers.

The boot isn’t the lightest or most breathable, but it’s tough to find this level of waterproofing and support at this price point. That makes it a go-to for folks who want reliability without breaking the bank.

Who It’s For (and Not For)

Who should consider it:

• Hikers, travelers, and outdoor workers who need waterproof boots for moderate terrain
• Anyone looking for a mix of durability and comfort without spending top dollar
• People who want boots that can double for casual wear

Who should probably skip it:

• Ultra-lightweight hikers and fastpackers who want the lightest shoes possible
• Folks hiking in very hot climates who need maximum airflow
• Anyone with extra-wide feet, unless they can try before buying

Key Specs

• Upper: Full-grain leather and mesh
• Waterproofing: Treated leather and seam-sealed construction
• Outsole: Omni-Grip rubber with multi-terrain tread
• Midsole: Lightweight Techlite cushioning
• Weight: Approx. 1.1–1.2 lbs per boot (size 11)
• Lacing: Metal eyelets and hooks for adjustable fit
• Sizes: Men’s 7–17 (some half sizes available)
• Colors: Cordovan/Squash and others

Decision Factors and Performance

If you’re deciding between comfort, support, and price, the Newton Ridge Plus II hits a practical middle ground. It’s not the softest or lightest, but it offers a secure fit, solid waterproofing, and enough grip for most trails.

The break-in period is worth considering—give yourself a few outings before judging the comfort. Sizing can run narrow, so wide-footed hikers might need to size up.

Durability is good for the price, though the softer rubber outsole may wear faster on pavement. For occasional hikers or daily walkers, it’s hard to beat the value.

Close Alternatives

Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof

• Differences: More breathable with a mesh-heavy upper, lighter weight, but not as durable in rough terrain.
• Best for: Hikers who want more airflow and a softer feel.

Salomon X Ultra Pioneer Mid ClimaSalomon Waterproof

• Differences: Sleeker, lighter, and more flexible, with a modern look and speed-lacing. Less classic leather durability.
• Best for: Fastpackers or anyone who wants a modern, athletic boot.

Strong Verdict

Columbia’s Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof Hiking Boot brings together classic leather toughness, reliable waterproofing, and a comfortable fit that works for most people. It’s not the lightest or coolest boot out there, but for the price, the value is hard to ignore.

If you need a solid all-around hiking boot for moderate trails and unpredictable weather, this one’s a dependable pick. Just watch the sizing if your feet are wide, and don’t expect it to feel like a trail runner on hot days.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do the Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II boots hold up under extreme hiking conditions?

They handle rocky and muddy trails well, thanks to the waterproof leather and sturdy outsole. The grip is solid, but the outsole rubber may wear faster if you hike on pavement a lot. Breathability is okay, but in hot climates, your feet might get warm.

What is the difference between the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II and the Newton Ridge Plus Amped?

The Amped version leans more stylish, with extra color options and slightly lighter materials. The Plus II uses more rugged leather for better durability. Both have similar waterproofing and grip, but the Amped isn’t as heavy-duty.

Can the Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II be considered a good value for their price point?

For the price, you get waterproofing, ankle support, and decent comfort. They’re not top-of-the-line, but the value is strong for casual hikers or outdoor workers. Hardcore backpackers might want something higher-end.

How does the fit of the Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II compare to other hiking boot brands?

Most people say they fit true to size, but some find them narrow. Compared to stiffer boots, these break in faster. The toe box is roomy enough for most, but if you have wide feet, you may want to size up.

What are the main pros and cons of the Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus II from a long-term wear perspective?

Pros

• Comfortable for daily use
• Waterproof leather holds up in rain and mud
• Good traction on dirt, rocks, and light snow

Cons

• Outsole may wear faster on hard surfaces
• Limited breathability in hot weather
• Not as much support as premium backpacking boots

Is there a significant difference in performance between the men's and women's versions of the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II boots?

You'll find that both versions perform almost identically. Columbia designed them to provide the same waterproofing, traction, and midsole cushioning.

The real difference comes down to fit and sizing. Columbia tweaks the shape to better match typical men's or women's feet, but doesn't change the core features.

If you're deciding between the two, try both on if you can. Go with the one that fits your foot best—performance won't be the deciding factor here.

Where to Buy

• Amazon
• Also available via the manufacturer and major retailers.